← Back to Case studies
FMCG distributionDistribution and logisticsillustrative example

ERP+WMS selection for a regional distributor

A food distributor with 3 warehouses avoided a failed implementation through a selection process based on its own scenarios, not on demos.

5 → 2vendors evaluated in detail
-31%5-year total cost vs. initial quote
10 wksselection duration

This case study is an illustrative example built from typical situations in our projects. Figures are indicative.

Context

Regional food distributor, 3 warehouses, ~90 employees, ~4,000 order lines per day. The existing system could no longer cope: inaccurate stock, paper picking, manual integrations with key accounts.

The challenge

The company had already received a quote from a vendor recommended by a partner, with a 6-month “standard” implementation. Management couldn’t assess whether the system covered its specifics: lots with expiry dates, multiple deliveries per day, complex commercial terms per customer.

The approach

We mapped the critical processes (receiving, picking, delivery, returns, invoicing) and wrote 22 test scenarios on the company’s data. We identified 5 suitable vendors, ran scripted demos with a common scoring grid, calculated the 5-year total cost and negotiated the contractual requirements and acceptance criteria alongside the client.

Results

The initially recommended system failed 6 of 22 scenarios. The chosen solution cost 31% less over 5 years and covered all critical scenarios. Implementation started with clarified processes and a contract with acceptance milestones – a completely different base from the starting point.

What's on your mind?

Describe your situation in a few sentences. Our assistant shows you within seconds which Smartbiz approaches would fit, then we talk specifics, with no commitment.